Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

California School Fiscal Services

Providing comprehensive business office and consulting services to K-12 traditional schools and charters



Important Case Decision flies under the radar while we were focused on Vergara, -- could drastically impact school district employee evaluations- Author: Jackie McHaney

Posted on August 1, 2014 at 2:25 PM

With all of our attention recently focused on the outcome of the Vergara decision, the recent Court of Appeal decision in Poole v. Orange County Fire Authority (2013) 221 Cal.App.4th 155, flew so low under the radar that it almost went unnoticed.


In Poole, Steve Poole was a firefighter with the Orange County Fire Authority (Fire Authority) from 2008 to 2010. As part of the evaluation process, Poole’s supervisor had a practice of maintaining daily logs on a flash drive and in a folder kept at his desk, to enable him to refresh his memory and assist him in preparing written evaluations. Poole’s supervisor asserted that the daily logs included the recording of “any factual occurrence or occurrences that would aid … in writing a thorough and fair annual review.” In the case at bar, it was determined that Poole’s supervisor made over one hundred handwritten and computerized notes, which documented the efficiency of Poole as well as other firefighters in the department, in carrying out their duties. In 2009, Poole’s supervisor, relying largely on his daily logs to aid in the preparation of the written evaluation, issued Poole a substandard evaluation because his “work habits, personal relations, adaptability, and progress were unsatisfactory.” As a result of this substandard evaluation, Poole was placed on a performance improvement plan.


Unsatisfied with his substandard evaluation, Poole (with the assistance of his union) sought copies of the daily logs, which included more than 100 entries regarding Poole, many of which described areas in need of improvement. Poole was provided copies of these documents. Upon receipt of these documents, Poole requested that all adverse comments in the daily logs be removed because he never had any opportunity to respond prior to their use for personnel purposes in his performance evaluation and subsequent improvement plan. The Fire Authority refused to remove the comments, contending that, even though the notes were for personnel purposes, they were never “entered” into any file used for personnel purposes. Rather, the Fire Authority contended that Poole had the opportunity to respond to the comments in the evaluation, which would be placed in the personnel file.


Poole lost at the trial court level. The trial court denied the petition, likening the daily logs to “post-it” notes that were intended to remind the supervisor of events when he prepared the annual performance evaluation. The trial court also pointed out that the parties conceded that if Poole’s supervisor had written Poole’s annual performance evaluation from his memory and not based on written recollections in the daily logs, there would have been no lawsuit. The trial court therefore concluded the daily logs were not part of the personnel file and Poole had no right to respond to the adverse comments. Poole and the union appealed the trial court decision.


On appeal, Poole and his union asked the court to order all adverse comments to be deleted from the daily logs pursuant to a provision of the Firefighters Procedural Bill of Rights Act (FBOR) that provides that adverse comments shall not be entered into a personnel file “or any other file used for any personnel purposes by his or her employer, without the firefighter having first read and signed the instrument containing the adverse comment indicating he or she is aware of the comment . . .” (Gov. Code, § 3255.) Obviously, the purpose of this request is to eliminate the ability of the Fire Authority to rely on these prior acts as a factual basis for the substandard performance evaluation and placement on the improvement plan.


In its review, the Court of Appeal relied heavily on an old California Supreme Court case, Miller v. Chico Unified School District, which interpreted an Education Code section regarding a teacher’s right to review and comment on information of a “derogatory nature” before placed in their personnel file. In Miller v. Chico Unified School District (1979) 24 Cal.3d 703, a school principal had been reassigned to a classroom position after the district’s governing board reviewed 20 (twenty) confidential memoranda prepared by an Associate Superintendent that the principal was unaware of. The California Supreme Court in Miller ultimately ordered the principal to be reinstated to his administrative position because the principal was not provided the opportunity to review or comment on the memoranda even though the district’s governing board made its decision based on these documents.


The Court held that the interpretation of the Education Code in the Miller decision should be applied to sections 3255 and 3256 of the FBOR. It noted that Poole’s supervisor’s daily logs were used for making personnel decisions and affected Poole’s employment status. Poole received a substandard annual performance evaluation and placed on an improvement plan, based upon the information maintained in the daily logs. (This of course discounts any independent recollection the supervisor may have had). The Court concluded that the FBOR was violated because the daily logs were used for personnel purposes. The Court noted that the FBOR’s right to respond to adverse comments that may affect personnel decisions “is frustrated when the firefighter’s supervisor maintains a daily log containing adverse comments that may reach as far back as the day after the firefighter’s last yearly evaluation and the adverse comments are not revealed to the firefighter until the next yearly review, at which point the firefighter may respond to adverse comments in that review.”


On February 26, 2014, the California Supreme Court granted a petition to review the recent Court of Appeal decision. It is important to understand, however, that if the Poole decision is upheld by the California Supreme Court, it will be problematic for school districts because many supervisors rely on informal notes compiled during an evaluation period to complete a thorough and accurate annual evaluation at the end of the year. Such a ruling will: (a) prohibit a supervisor from keeping or maintaining any negative notes or comments or documents regarding an employee unless the employee was provided a prompt opportunity to review and comment upon each separate note or comment; and (b) will require supervisors to start documenting every incident deemed worthy of consideration for inclusion in an evaluation, provide each employee with a separate comment or note and an opportunity to respond to it, and then place all of these documents into their personnel file – which we know employees will not respond well too.


Hopefully, the Supreme Court will conclude that an individual negative note or comment kept in an employee’s pending evaluation file and kept solely for the purposes of aiding in recollection to ensure accuracy in the preparation of the annual evaluation does not trigger a separate due process requirement. In the alternative, we could add “Photographic” or ‘Eidetic” memory to the list of qualifications required for supervisors, if our only alternatives are to prepare evaluations solely from memory or increase our file cabinet budget because of the size our personnel files will need to be now to accommodate the additional documentation the Poole decision may end up requiring be maintained in the personnel file, in addition to the evaluation document that essentially summarizes the same.


Welcome back to the new school year!


Categories: Lawsuits, Leadership

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.


Reply Suejeaky
9:41 PM on May 25, 2022 
how can i get propecia
Reply Lisajeaky
9:27 PM on May 25, 2022 
cheapest levitra generic without prescription
Reply supreme clothing
8:28 PM on May 25, 2022 
I'm commenting to let you be aware of what a excellent encounter our daughter had browsing your web site. She realized too many details, which included how it is like to possess an incredible teaching nature to have a number of people without hassle fully grasp various grueling things. You truly exceeded our own expected results. I appreciate you for presenting those warm and friendly, safe, informative and in addition easy thoughts on that topic to Lizeth.
supreme clothing
Reply moncler jackets
6:38 PM on May 25, 2022 
My wife and i were really relieved Emmanuel could conclude his web research while using the precious recommendations he got through the site. It's not at all simplistic to simply find yourself making a gift of concepts which often the rest may have been selling. And now we understand we need the writer to give thanks to for that. All of the illustrations you made, the straightforward blog menu, the relationships you will help to promote - it's many spectacular, and it's really facilitating our son in addition to the family believe that this idea is awesome, which is extremely serious. Thanks for the whole thing!
moncler jackets
Reply Ivyjeaky
5:56 PM on May 25, 2022 
retino a
Reply Pauljeaky
5:29 PM on May 25, 2022 
prinivil medication
Reply lebron shoes
3:17 PM on May 25, 2022 
I must get across my admiration for your generosity giving support to persons that have the need for assistance with in this idea. Your personal commitment to passing the message across had been definitely significant and have regularly made somebody just like me to get to their endeavors. Your informative suggestions can mean a whole lot a person like me and even further to my office workers. Thanks a ton; from each one of us.
lebron shoes
Reply Janejeaky
2:00 PM on May 25, 2022 
how much is strattera
Reply bape clothing
11:43 AM on May 25, 2022 
I wanted to post a word to be able to say thanks to you for these superb techniques you are giving at this website. My prolonged internet search has now been recognized with pleasant ideas to go over with my great friends. I 'd assert that many of us readers actually are rather lucky to live in a fine site with many marvellous professionals with great points. I feel extremely privileged to have used your web page and look forward to some more exciting times reading here. Thanks a lot once more for a lot of things.
bape clothing
Reply kd 12
11:43 AM on May 25, 2022 
Thank you a lot for giving everyone an extremely terrific opportunity to read critical reviews from this site. It can be very excellent and stuffed with a lot of fun for me and my office peers to visit your blog not less than three times weekly to find out the fresh stuff you have got. And lastly, I'm just at all times impressed with all the dazzling tactics you serve. Certain 2 ideas on this page are definitely the most efficient we've ever had.
kd 12
Reply supreme outlet
11:42 AM on May 25, 2022 
Thanks a lot for giving everyone an exceptionally superb chance to read in detail from this site. It is usually very brilliant and as well , full of a good time for me personally and my office mates to visit your web site a minimum of thrice in 7 days to learn the newest issues you have got. Of course, we are at all times astounded with all the magnificent hints you serve. Certain 4 ideas in this posting are surely the most impressive we have ever had.
supreme outlet
Reply kevin durant
11:42 AM on May 25, 2022 
I precisely desired to thank you very much again. I do not know the things I would have worked on without these aspects revealed by you regarding such a concern. This was a horrifying difficulty for me, however , witnessing your skilled avenue you solved the issue forced me to cry with delight. Extremely grateful for this information and in addition hope you realize what a great job you are always putting in educating men and women by way of your webpage. Most probably you haven't got to know any of us.
kevin durant
Reply supreme new york
11:42 AM on May 25, 2022 
I want to voice my gratitude for your kind-heartedness for men and women that have the need for help with in this idea. Your very own dedication to passing the solution up and down appears to be surprisingly informative and has truly helped employees just like me to reach their targets. Your amazing important hints and tips indicates a whole lot a person like me and further more to my mates. Thanks a ton; from each one of us.
supreme new york
Reply golden goose
11:42 AM on May 25, 2022 
I simply needed to say thanks again. I am not sure what I could possibly have used without the information discussed by you directly on that area. It had been an absolute intimidating difficulty in my position, but taking a look at the very professional manner you handled the issue made me to weep with fulfillment. Extremely thankful for this assistance and even wish you find out what a great job you have been getting into teaching others with the aid of your web page. I'm certain you haven't encountered all of us.
golden goose
Reply air jordan
11:41 AM on May 25, 2022 
I and my guys have been checking out the nice suggestions from your web site and then the sudden I had a horrible feeling I had not expressed respect to the blog owner for those secrets. My people appeared to be as a result warmed to see them and already have without a doubt been enjoying those things. Many thanks for indeed being really accommodating and then for having such high-quality things most people are really wanting to learn about. My sincere regret for not expressing gratitude to sooner.
air jordan
Reply golden goose outlet
11:12 AM on May 25, 2022 
I intended to draft you this very little remark to finally give thanks yet again regarding the pleasant principles you have documented on this website. It's surprisingly open-handed of you to convey easily exactly what a few people would've advertised for an e-book to earn some cash on their own, certainly since you could possibly have tried it if you ever decided. Those techniques additionally acted as the easy way to know that someone else have a similar interest similar to mine to grasp a great deal more when it comes to this issue. I think there are lots of more enjoyable situations in the future for people who scan your blog.
golden goose outlet
Reply Ivyjeaky
5:13 AM on May 25, 2022 
lisinopril 10 mg brand name in india
Reply off white nike
12:46 AM on May 25, 2022 
Thanks a lot for providing individuals with such a remarkable chance to read in detail from this blog. It's usually so superb and jam-packed with fun for me personally and my office fellow workers to search the blog on the least thrice in a week to see the latest stuff you have got. Of course, I am always satisfied concerning the staggering techniques you give. Some 1 areas in this posting are in truth the most efficient we have all ever had.
off white nike
Reply kyrie irving shoes
10:02 PM on May 24, 2022 
I am also writing to let you know of the brilliant experience my cousin's girl developed reading through the blog. She figured out a good number of pieces, which include what it's like to have a very effective helping style to let many others without difficulty know precisely specified hard to do subject matter. You truly surpassed visitors' expectations. I appreciate you for presenting these productive, trusted, educational and even unique guidance on this topic to Emily.
kyrie irving shoes