Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

California School Fiscal Services

Providing comprehensive business office and consulting services to K-12 traditional schools and charters



Local control formula closing funding gap but not equity gap, report says

Posted on April 10, 2017 at 7:30 PM

Ed Source



Four years after its passage, the Local Control Funding Formula has narrowed and, by some measures, reversed the funding gap between the lowest- and highest-poverty districts in California.

But an infusion of funding hasn’t translated yet into improved opportunities for low-income students and English learners ­– and may not achieve that goal without tighter disclosure rules and more innovative approaches to distributing districts’ resources, a student advocacy organization said in a report published Thursday.

“We need more clarity on where money is going. Without transparency, community stakeholders, policymakers and the broader public are left to wonder whether this massive public experiment and investment is paying off,” said the Education Trust–West in “The Steep Road to Resource Equity in California Education.”

The funding formula gives additional money to school districts based on their numbers of English learners, foster youth and low-income students. A district whose “high-needs” students make up about 90 percent of enrollment, such as Fresno Unified, will get about a third more funding in “supplemental” and “concentration” dollars under the formula than districts like Dublin Unified, with 15 percent high-needs students.

The formula is working as intended to close funding disparities, the report found. Funding for the quarter of districts with the highest concentrations of poverty got $334 per student more in 2015-16 than the quarter of districts with the lowest rates of poverty. That’s a reversal from the low point of the Great Recession, 2012-13, when the highest-poverty districts got $829 per student less than those with the lowest poverty levels. The comparison is all the more striking because it includes local sources of money, such as parcel taxes and money from local foundations. It also includes high-wealth “basic aid” districts, like Palo Alto, that are funded through local property taxes and receive more money than they would from the state.

A table in the report of the state’s largest districts shows that per-student funding for Elk Grove Unified, with 58 percent high-needs students – about the state average – increased 41 percent since 2010-11, compared with 59 percent for Santa Ana Unified, with 94 percent high-needs students.

But the report, using limited data, said the money hasn’t yet translated into visible improvements for high-needs students statewide. The percentage of students in high-poverty high schools with access to math and English language arts courses qualifying for admission to California State University and the University of California stagnated or declined since pre-recession levels, although access to calculus and physics courses did increase. Access to all of these courses was significantly lower than in wealthier high schools.

The state does not collect data on how districts use supplemental and concentration money. The latest data on course access and numbers of counselors and librarians in low- and high-poverty schools were from 2014-15, the second year of funding under the formula. There have been significant funding increases in the past two years that were not accounted for in the report.

But Ryan Smith, Education Trust–West’s executive director, said that the complaints he continues to hear from parent and community leaders across the state back the report’s early-year findings that “district leaders aren’t spending money in the best interest of kids who generate the funds.”

This week, the nonprofit law firm Public Advocates filed a complaint against Long Beach Unified, alleging the state’s third-largest district either failed to explain how it had spent more than $40 million in supplemental and concentration money for high-needs students or had misallocated the funding. Referring to that action, Smith said, “We believe (the funding formula) can be the lynchpin to close the opportunity and achievement gaps. But rather than go down the road where every district is sued for not spending money on the kids, we are raising a yellow flag now.”

Education Trust–West’s report coincides with a push to pass funding transparency legislation that it and Children Now, another student advocacy organization, are cosponsoring. Assembly Bill 1321, by Assemblywoman Shirley Weber, D-San Diego, would require districts to specify how they are spending their supplemental and concentration dollars at the district and the school levels. Some districts already are doing this on their own. The bill would require uniform state codes to track these expenditures across districts.

The current law requires that districts show they are improving or increasing services for high-needs students in proportion to the extra money they’re getting, but they’re not required to itemize supplemental and concentration spending. And Gov. Jerry Brown, the architect of the funding formula, opposes requiring more detailed accounting at the school level. He and his appointed State Board of Education maintain that improvement strategies must radiate from the district to be effective and that administrators and school boards should be held accountable for improvement under local control.

Smith said that approach may make sense for a small district but not an urban district with hundreds of schools and a disconnected central office. “Parents engage at their school site, not L.A. Unified’s district office, to get their information and become involved,” he said.

The report calls for protecting districts’ flexibility over funding decisions and guarding against revisions to the formula that would increase base funding for general operations, at the expense of supplemental and concentration dollars. Education Trust–West and critics of the current formula do agree districts’ rising pension costs – a state-mandated expense not foreseen when the formula was created – and rising special education costs could easily consume more than half of base revenues in coming years. Those districts with declining enrollments will see a reduction in state revenue.

In a sober assessment, the report acknowledged, “With these cost pressures, districts will have very few new, incremental dollars available to increase and improve services” for high-need groups.

“This means thinking beyond the supplemental and concentration grants,” the report said. Districts should use the entire budget, integrating disparate sources of funding, to expand their strategies for high-need students.

The report highlights San Jose Unified, which it said uses an exemplary approach to equitable funding. The district, whose schools vary greatly in demographics and wealth, has directed significant staff and resources to high-poverty schools and given principals flexibility over allocating money. Members of the state board and other observers point to other districts’ equity-focused strategies and say San Jose’s strategy is far from unique.

Categories: None

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.


Reply Zakjeaky
7:34 AM on September 4, 2021 
can you order cialis online cheapest pharmacy to fill prescriptions without insurance viagra 50mg for sale buy cialis 10mg uk
Reply Yonjeaky
7:09 AM on September 4, 2021 
effexor 75mg coupon viagra 100mg cheap price cialis in canada over the counter propecia canada price where to buy stromectol where to get zithromax over the counter
Reply Boojeaky
4:45 AM on September 4, 2021 
cialis coupon canada online pharmacy products how to buy generic cialis kamagra discount uk generic viagra 50mg price where to buy sildenafil online viagra 100mg price usa
Reply Ugojeaky
4:45 AM on September 4, 2021 
viagra in usa prescription buy modafinil online without prescription canadian cialis online citalopram 40mg tablet where can i buy cialis tablets tadalafil cost india
Reply Wimjeaky
1:19 AM on September 4, 2021 
100mg sildenafil price super saver pharmacy can you buy propecia over the counter reliable online pharmacy effexor 100mg priligy mexico
Reply Teojeaky
11:33 PM on September 3, 2021 
where to buy viagra 50mg online stromectol cost discount viagra for sale viagra otc in canada pharmacy online australia free shipping cialis india online
Reply Ugojeaky
8:54 PM on September 3, 2021 
100 viagra pill purchase viagra online from canada canada pharmacy online legit no rx pharmacy
Reply Tedjeaky
6:39 PM on September 3, 2021 
buy priligy online uk buy clomid online no prescription sildenafil 25 mg india buy black cialis online buy viagra europe viagra online canada paypal
Reply Wimjeaky
4:13 PM on September 3, 2021 
buy modafinil online cheap where to purchase tadalafil online buy sildenafil online canada ivermectin medicine buy viagra pills online uk where can i buy modafinil can you purchase viagra in mexico
Reply Boojeaky
2:14 PM on September 3, 2021 
name brand viagra online ivermectin generic buy cheap viagra online canadian pharmacy cheap generic tadalafil where to buy cheap tadalafil best generic sildenafil where can i get valtrex
Reply Ashjeaky
1:19 PM on September 3, 2021 
how to get modafinil without prescription canada drug sildenafil tadalafil where to get cheap tadalafil pills
Reply Tedjeaky
12:23 PM on September 3, 2021 
inderal 40mg 80mg how much does ivermectin cost sildenafil prescription uk where to buy prednisolone finpecia online india generic tadalafil coupon viagra 100mg uk price how to buy cialis online in australia
Reply Ashjeaky
8:51 AM on September 3, 2021 
viagra price malaysia can you buy propecia over the counter in canada mypharmacy zofran in mexico sildenafil pharmacy online
Reply Wimjeaky
1:47 AM on September 3, 2021 
zithromax cream plaquenil 500 mg cialis 5mg nz hydroxychloroquine plaquenil cost
Reply Boojeaky
11:36 PM on September 2, 2021 
generic sildenafil cost usa viagra 1 tablet ivermectin 3mg dose buy ivermectin sildenafil 20 mg pill how much is the cost of viagra viagra pharmacy best online foreign pharmacies
Reply Yonjeaky
11:07 PM on September 2, 2021 
levaquin buy canadian cialis online sildenafil 2.5 canadian pharmacy tadalafil cialis for daily use 5mg where can i buy xenical tablets online
Reply Zakjeaky
10:29 PM on September 2, 2021 
buy ivermectin uk buy viagra in europe
Reply Tedjeaky
7:51 PM on September 2, 2021 
sky pharmacy cialis on sale cialis 2.5 mg price comparison sildenafil 100g best tadalafil prices roche accutane cost cialis 5 mg
Reply Ugojeaky
6:19 PM on September 2, 2021 
buy sildenafil india online best cheap cialis modafinil cheap uk best cheap viagra pills where can i buy modafinil uk
Reply Zakjeaky
3:45 PM on September 2, 2021 
cialis coupon canada where can i buy over the counter cialis sildenafil generic costs