Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

California School Fiscal Services

Providing comprehensive business office and consulting services to K-12 traditional schools and charters



Appeals Court denies constitutional right to minimum K-12 funding

Posted on April 24, 2016 at 4:45 PM
Two really important points jump out at me here...

1.  The California Court of Appeal's doesn't believe that the Constitution is responsible for defining what is considered "adequate" funding. This doesn't mean that they agree or disagree that our current level of funding is adequate - just that it's not their call.

2.  "Even after restoring lost revenue, California will remain the lowest in the nation in per-student staffing levels."  This is easy for many to forget  when we are in the midst of receiving year-over-year increases to LCFF.  



By John Fensterwald | April 20, 2016 | 2 Comments


The state Constitution does not guarantee children in California a minimally funded quality education, a divided California Court of Appeal ruled Wednesday in a landmark decision closely watched by proponents of more K-12 spending.


The 2-1 decision on two six-year-old lawsuits denies the California School Boards Association and student advocacy groups the right to a trial to make the case that underfunding by the Legislature is denying students the quality education they’re entitled to. The plaintiffs immediately said they would appeal the ruling to the California Supreme Court.


The San Francisco-based 1st District Court of Appeal ruled on separate but related lawsuits filed in 2010: Campaign for Quality Education v. State of California, filed by Public Advocates on behalf of five nonprofits serving low-income, minority families, and Robles-Wong et al. v. State of California, jointly filed by the school boards association, the state PTA, the Association of California School Administrators and the California Teachers Association, together with Stanford Law Professor William Koski, representing low-income children.


Both lawsuits argued that the state’s “insufficient, irrational and unstable” school funding system failed to provide students their constitutional right to a quality education. The Legislature spelled out what that entails by imposing graduation requirements, rigorous academic standards and other mandates, but didn’t provide school districts with enough resources to meet the demands, the lawsuit argued.


In his majority decision, Associate Justice Martin Jenkins acknowledged children’s fundamental right to an education, which the 137-year-old state Constitution broadly defines as the obligation to “encourage by all suitable means the promotion of intellectual, scientific, moral and agricultural improvement.” But the Constitution doesn’t include a requirement for a minimum quality level of education for schoolchildren, Jenkins wrote, or a minimum level of expenditures for education.


“We agree wholeheartedly with appellants that the provision of a quality education for all public school students is an important goal for society,” he wrote, but it’s the Legislature’s prerogative to determine what quality means. Jenkins quoted a school funding decision from Illinois that said judges lack the expertise to set appropriate levels of school funding; assuming that responsibility would preempt the public’s right, through open dialogue with elected officials, to do so.


In a concurring opinion, Associate Justice Peter Siggins wrote, “As much as I can appreciate the plaintiffs’ frustration and dissatisfaction with the overall adequacy of California’s public schools, and recognize our Legislature’s challenges in adequately funding schools to meet the standards it sets, I cannot agree” that the Constitution provides a right to “command the state to fund schools at some qualitative level.” If large numbers of students are underachieving, there are other legal remedies without expanding a constitutional right, he said.


But in his dissent, Associate Justice Stuart Pollak disagreed with the conclusion that there is no minimum requirement to support schools. The Constitution’s mandate to provide education “implies the need to maintain public schools at some minimum level of competence,” he wrote. Not only do the courts have a responsibility to determine whether the allegations of minimum funding are valid, but “the courts are capable of fulfilling that responsibility,” and providing “meaningful relief” if needed, he stated.


Both lawsuits were filed at a time of big state budget cuts for education, and the court of appeal considered only the arguments in the briefs presented to Alameda County Superior Court Judge Steven Brick in 2010. Since then, the Legislature has restored most of the funding lost during the recession and adopted challenging academic standards – the Common Core and the Next Generation Science Standards. Pollak alluded to the changing circumstances in writing: “Should these actions proceed to trial, the focus would of course be on current conditions to the extent that relevant data is available. Nonetheless, despite changes – hopefully improvements – that have occurred more recently, the fundamental issues raised by the complaints remain.”


California’s Constitution “requires a system that provides students with a meaningful basic education in reality as well as on paper,” he wrote.


John Affeldt, managing attorney for Public Advocates, said in an interview that even after restoring lost revenue, California will remain the lowest in the nation in per-student staffing levels, and the Legislature has not sufficiently provided enough funding to deliver quality academic standards for all students.


He said that he and the other plaintiffs disagree with the majority opinion that a fundamental right doesn’t guarantee “a minimum quality.” That right would be hollow without it, he said.


Confirming that the plaintiffs in Robles-Wong will also appeal the decision, California School Boards Association CEO & Executive Director Vernon Billy said in a statement, “Today’s decision is truly disappointing for California’s students and families. We firmly believe all students in California have a fundamental right to an education that meets the standards the state has set – and that is currently being denied to many, especially low-income students and students of color.”



Categories: Lawsuits

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.


Reply off white hoodie
5:14 PM on July 2, 2022 
I actually wanted to jot down a small message to thank you for all the precious pointers you are sharing on this site. My long internet look up has at the end of the day been recognized with beneficial facts to write about with my close friends. I 'd point out that most of us readers are really endowed to exist in a superb community with very many marvellous individuals with very helpful tips. I feel very lucky to have come across your webpage and look forward to really more fabulous minutes reading here. Thanks a lot again for everything.
off white hoodie
Reply golden goose
5:13 PM on July 2, 2022 
I precisely wanted to say thanks once more. I am not sure what I could possibly have tried without the advice revealed by you relating to such a theme. It was actually a challenging concern in my position, but encountering the very specialized fashion you handled it took me to weep with fulfillment. I will be happier for the help and thus hope that you are aware of an amazing job your are doing educating people today via your site. I'm certain you haven't come across all of us.
golden goose
Reply golden goose sneakers
8:57 AM on July 1, 2022 
I truly wanted to construct a quick comment in order to appreciate you for the fantastic guidelines you are placing on this site. My time intensive internet research has at the end of the day been compensated with really good facts and strategies to talk about with my guests. I would believe that most of us visitors actually are unquestionably lucky to be in a good website with so many outstanding people with valuable guidelines. I feel rather grateful to have encountered your website page and look forward to some more enjoyable moments reading here. Thanks once more for all the details.
golden goose sneakers
Reply russell westbrook shoes
8:57 AM on July 1, 2022 
I wanted to type a small message to be able to say thanks to you for all of the fantastic items you are placing here. My incredibly long internet investigation has finally been rewarded with good information to write about with my friends and family. I 'd repeat that most of us readers actually are very much lucky to be in a notable website with very many awesome professionals with insightful plans. I feel really lucky to have come across your entire weblog and look forward to so many more brilliant minutes reading here. Thanks a lot once more for everything.
russell westbrook shoes
Reply golden goose shoes
8:57 AM on July 1, 2022 
I as well as my buddies came looking through the excellent strategies on your web blog and so suddenly I got an awful feeling I never thanked the web site owner for those strategies. These men are actually absolutely thrilled to study all of them and have now truly been using these things. I appreciate you for truly being so thoughtful and also for making a choice on such magnificent subject areas most people are really needing to discover. My very own honest regret for not saying thanks to you earlier.
golden goose shoes
Reply off white shoes
8:57 AM on July 1, 2022 
I wish to express my affection for your kindness giving support to those who really want assistance with this niche. Your very own commitment to getting the message along had been unbelievably functional and has all the time encouraged folks just like me to arrive at their targets. Your own interesting guidelines implies much a person like me and even more to my office colleagues. Warm regards; from all of us.
off white shoes
Reply moncler coat
8:57 AM on July 1, 2022 
I would like to convey my passion for your kind-heartedness for those people that really want help on this one study. Your special commitment to getting the message all-around was definitely powerful and has all the time allowed those like me to get to their goals. Your interesting guide indicates this much a person like me and additionally to my fellow workers. Warm regards; from all of us.
moncler coat
Reply yeezy 700
8:57 AM on July 1, 2022 
My husband and i ended up being so ecstatic John managed to round up his basic research through the entire ideas he discovered out of the blog. It is now and again perplexing to just possibly be giving away secrets which often men and women may have been making money from. We really figure out we have the blog owner to be grateful to because of that. The explanations you've made, the straightforward site menu, the relationships you will help to engender - it's got all spectacular, and it is letting our son and the family reason why the article is excellent, which is certainly particularly serious. Thanks for everything!
yeezy 700
Reply supreme clothing
8:57 AM on July 1, 2022 
I simply needed to appreciate you once again. I am not sure the things I could possibly have implemented in the absence of the entire tips contributed by you concerning this subject. It actually was an absolute difficult case in my view, nevertheless witnessing a new specialized way you dealt with that forced me to cry with fulfillment. I will be happier for your service and even hope you know what a great job that you're providing training men and women via your blog post. Most likely you have never got to know all of us.
supreme clothing
Reply yeezy wave runner 700
8:56 AM on July 1, 2022 
I definitely wanted to jot down a small remark so as to thank you for the unique items you are placing on this website. My particularly long internet look up has at the end of the day been rewarded with reputable content to go over with my relatives. I would declare that many of us visitors actually are undeniably lucky to dwell in a wonderful site with many marvellous people with useful tactics. I feel rather lucky to have used the site and look forward to so many more pleasurable times reading here. Thank you once more for all the details.
yeezy wave runner 700
Reply birkin bag
8:56 AM on July 1, 2022 
I would like to get across my appreciation for your generosity giving support to individuals who should have guidance on this situation. Your real commitment to getting the message along ended up being especially useful and have helped girls just like me to get to their targets. Your new warm and helpful hints and tips indicates this much a person like me and even more to my colleagues. With thanks; from all of us.
birkin bag
Reply longchamp
8:56 AM on July 1, 2022 
I enjoy you because of all your efforts on this web site. My mother take interest in getting into investigations and it is obvious why. We all notice all regarding the lively mode you present both interesting and useful secrets on the web blog and therefore invigorate response from website visitors on this concept plus our princess is now studying a lot. Take pleasure in the rest of the new year. You are conducting a great job.
Reply paul george
10:34 PM on June 29, 2022 
My husband and i got really satisfied Edward could finish off his survey through the entire ideas he got when using the weblog. It's not at all simplistic to simply choose to be offering tips and tricks that many people today have been trying to sell. We really grasp we now have the writer to appreciate because of that. The type of illustrations you've made, the easy web site menu, the friendships you will aid to engender - it's got most fabulous, and it is aiding our son and us know that the topic is fun, and that's truly mandatory. Many thanks for the whole thing!
paul george
Reply golden goose
10:34 PM on June 29, 2022 
I definitely wanted to post a simple word to be able to say thanks to you for some of the amazing concepts you are writing here. My long internet investigation has finally been rewarded with wonderful points to write about with my company. I would claim that most of us visitors are very much fortunate to be in a notable network with many special individuals with helpful points. I feel very fortunate to have encountered the weblog and look forward to so many more enjoyable times reading here. Thanks again for everything.
golden goose
Reply cheap jordans
10:34 PM on June 29, 2022 
My husband and i felt really delighted Edward managed to deal with his research from the precious recommendations he acquired when using the weblog. It's not at all simplistic just to be giving for free strategies that many many others might have been selling. And we also do understand we have the writer to appreciate for that. All of the illustrations you've made, the simple website menu, the relationships you can make it easier to create - it's got all extraordinary, and it is facilitating our son and the family reckon that the issue is cool, and that is tremendously indispensable. Many thanks for all!
cheap jordans
Reply kd shoes
10:34 PM on June 29, 2022 
Thanks a lot for providing individuals with remarkably splendid possiblity to read articles and blog posts from this site. It really is very excellent and jam-packed with a lot of fun for me and my office mates to visit your blog no less than thrice a week to read the new tips you have. Not to mention, I'm so always impressed with all the good tips and hints served by you. Certain 4 areas in this posting are really the best I've had.
kd shoes
Reply air jordan
10:34 PM on June 29, 2022 
I wish to express some thanks to the writer for rescuing me from such a predicament. Just after exploring throughout the the web and getting notions which are not powerful, I figured my entire life was well over. Being alive without the presence of answers to the difficulties you've sorted out all through the report is a crucial case, as well as the ones which may have in a wrong way affected my career if I hadn't encountered your web blog. Your own personal talents and kindness in handling the whole lot was tremendous. I'm not sure what I would've done if I hadn't come across such a thing like this. It's possible to now look ahead to my future. Thanks a lot very much for this specialized and results-oriented help. I won't hesitate to propose your blog to anyone who requires guide about this issue.
air jordan
Reply adidas yeezy
10:34 PM on June 29, 2022 
Needed to post you one very small observation to be able to say thanks a lot as before relating to the striking techniques you've contributed on this page. It's simply tremendously generous with you to convey unhampered exactly what numerous people could have distributed as an e book to end up making some bucks for their own end, mostly considering the fact that you could have tried it in case you wanted. Those tricks as well worked like the easy way to be sure that someone else have the identical interest like my personal own to figure out a whole lot more concerning this condition. I think there are many more pleasant periods in the future for folks who examine your blog post.
adidas yeezy
Reply supreme
10:34 PM on June 29, 2022 
Thanks for your entire work on this web site. Kim enjoys conducting investigation and it's really simple to grasp why. A lot of people learn all about the lively manner you deliver helpful tips and hints through the website and as well as increase participation from some others about this subject plus our own child has always been understanding a whole lot. Have fun with the rest of the new year. Your performing a dazzling job.
Reply golden goose sneakers
10:34 PM on June 29, 2022 
I wanted to write down a quick message to be able to appreciate you for all the remarkable concepts you are writing on this site. My rather long internet investigation has now been compensated with useful information to share with my visitors. I 'd admit that we website visitors actually are extremely fortunate to exist in a good site with so many brilliant professionals with great suggestions. I feel extremely privileged to have discovered your web pages and look forward to plenty of more awesome minutes reading here. Thank you again for all the details.
golden goose sneakers