Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
Quantity:
Subtotal
Taxes
Shipping
Total
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

California School Fiscal Services

Providing comprehensive business office and consulting services to K-12 traditional schools and charters

Blog

Blog

Fresno Unified leaders reject hiring outside investigator on leaseback deal

Posted on June 25, 2015 at 11:15 AM
Allegations of violating the Brown Act will result in your losing credibility and it opens you up to public scrutiny.  
We all know the rules so when you choose to ignore them, you are rolling the dice as to whether or not you are the next newspaper article on the subject matter.  

This article is a direct result of the recent court ruling on the legality of lease-lease back.  I do disagree with the reporters interpretation of the purpose of lease-lease back - "Lease-leaseback contracts are traditionally used to help poor or small school districts build schools by allowing them to lease the land where they plan to build to a contractor for a small amount, and then the contractor pays all the upfront costs."  I don't agree that it was used to "help poor or small school districts"....

Rather, it has been used as a way of avoid the competitive bid process.  In the end, it's not your money, it's the taxpapyers.  Follow the rules and don't play games with the Brown Act.  It's a pretty simple code to live by but as you will read, not everyone has the same code in our industry.
 
------------------------------

BY MACKENZIE MAYS

[email protected]

Fresno Unified School District leaders have denied bids by school board members to schedule a vote on hiring an independent investigator to examine a controversial construction deal.

 

So trustees Brook Ashjian, Carol Mills and Luis Chavez are taking their campaign public. On Tuesday, The Bee published a letter to the editor from the three, who urged their fellow board members to consider an outside investigation. Ashjian, Mills and Chavez say it’s time for an independent probe into a lease-leaseback deal the district had with Harris Construction to build Rutherford B. Gaston Middle School that was recently deemed illegal.

 

Although Superintendent Michael Hanson has proposed an internal investigation, the three board members are hoping an outside investigation will provide more transparency about the details of the case. But their requests to get the item onto the board’s meeting agenda have been denied or ignored.

 

According to emails obtained by The Bee, School Board President Cal Johnson denied a request by Ashjian to have the matter put on the agenda at a special meeting last week.

 

When Ashjian asked why the request was denied, Johnson pointed to the Brown Act — legislation created to guarantee the public’s right to participate in government meetings.

 

Johnson also pointed to Fresno Unified bylaws that say the superintendent and board president are in charge of preparing meeting agendas.

 

Johnson acknowledged that members of the board or public can request that items be placed on agendas, but he and the superintendent have the “ultimate authority” and “sole responsibility” of deciding what gets addressed.

 

BOARD BYLAW 9322 … GIVES THE SUPERINTENDENT AND BOARD PRESIDENT SOLE RESPONSIBILITY FOR DETERMINING WHETHER AN ITEM IS APPROPRIATE FOR PLACEMENT ON THE AGENDA.

 

“After consulting with the superintendent, board leadership has determined that it would be premature to consider your request at this time,” Johnson said in the email.

 

Johnson said the staff is in the process of reviewing the contracts in question. Before any related items can be placed on the agenda, the superintendent and his staff should have the opportunity to “thoroughly assess the impact of the Davis decision and the use of lease-leaseback in constructing district facilities,” he wrote in the email.

 

Johnson and Hanson did not comment on whether the item would be added to next month’s meeting. Amy Idsvoog, interim chief information officer for Fresno Unified, said Tuesday that the district is looking at ways to modify its contracts concerning lease-leaseback issues. “In the meantime, our Board of Education has asked the Supreme Court to provide further direction,” she said. Idsvoog did not say if the item would be added to next month’s agenda.

 

Peter Scheer, an attorney and director of the First Amendment Coalition based in San Rafael, said he has received many calls from frustrated government agencies, including school boards, expressing the concern that leaders manipulate the Brown Act to filter what is addressed in public meetings.

 

The power to assemble meeting agendas is typically in the hands of one or two leaders on a board, but historically, that has caused conflict and frustration, Scheer said.

 

“I’m sympathetic to any organization, any city council or school board, that puzzles over what is the process for deciding what goes on the agenda. To me, it’s just one of those things that they forgot about in the Brown Act,” he said. “Obviously it would be ironic —perverse, frankly, for the act to be interpreted to invest all the power in one person. The point of the act is to facilitate democracy, but sometimes it’s exactly the opposite.”

 

The board members are concerned that an internal investigation would pose a conflict of interest. If the motion never makes it on the agenda and an independent investigator is not hired, then details about the case will remain unclear. At least one member of the public has also stepped forward asking for an outside investigation.

 

Ashjian said he’s not sure what the next step will be, but he’s determined to have the facts aired publicly.

 

“They want to investigate themselves when they were the ones that caused the problem,” he said. “I don’t know how we’re supposed to talk about this thing if they won’t allow it on the agenda, but people want transparency.”

 

The Fifth District Court of Appeal recently found that the district sidestepped the competitive bidding process to the benefit of Harris Construction and in violation of state law.

 

Lease-leaseback contracts are traditionally used to help poor or small school districts build schools by allowing them to lease the land where they plan to build to a contractor for a small amount, and then the contractor pays all the upfront costs. The district then “leases back” the building from the contractor and pays down the project costs over several years. But in this case, Fresno Unified had the money, which has led to allegations that the deal was made solely to ensure Harris Construction got the bid.

 

Fresno Unified has come under fire before for not allowing items to be added to the board agenda, despite pleas from board members and the public. In 2012, former board member Michelle Asadoorian went public about being silenced by board leadership. Asadoorian claimed various requests to address a controversial residency issue involving then president Tony Vang were repeatedly denied.

 

Mackenzie Mays: 559-441-6412, @MackenzieMays

 

Read more here: http://www.fresnobee.com/news/local/education/article25371361.html#storylink=cpy


Categories: Ethics

Post a Comment

Oops!

Oops, you forgot something.

Oops!

The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

4155 Comments

Reply tonatsuma
8:57 PM on November 27, 2022 
air force 1 low first use sparkle tulle flower girl dresses new balance 360 mens cologne detroit red wings mens customized red jersey adidas yeezy boost 650 triple white cheap black white and red shoes new balance 501 womens noir
tonatsuma http://www.tonatsuma.com/
Reply proevalua
7:28 PM on November 27, 2022 
ellie crossbody with rivets easiest crochet messy bun hat reebok question mid x hall of fame 42.5 outlet mall coach handbags jordan 13s may 1st chanel 5203
proevalua http://www.proevalua.net/
Reply saglikara
7:50 AM on November 26, 2022 
auguste josie molly maxi dress pandora disney charms 2018 asics novablast slam jam ray ban wayfarer 2140 havana moncler wool and down jacket roquan smith bears jersey
saglikara http://www.saglikara.net/
Reply mytapbath
4:43 AM on November 25, 2022 
women 2014 new nfl jerseys new york jets 87 eric decker drift fashion green elite jerseys new england patriot winter hats for uk boys dress style 2020 vintage lemon dress east carolina pirates top of the world ncaa sunrise adjustable cap reebok jj iii shoes
mytapbath http://www.mytapbath.com/
Reply afidmex
7:38 AM on November 24, 2022 
green spurs jersey faroe islands soccer jersey adidas ozweego bunny raf simons core black grey low jordan 1 the north face summit series l6 pink versace sneakers
afidmex http://www.afidmex.com/
Reply calaera
8:04 PM on November 22, 2022 
ny giants gray hoodie
calaera http://www.calaera.net/
Reply muadotho
10:03 PM on November 20, 2022 
dr martens hanley high black and white jordans jd white and yellow striped dress joe montana framed autographed jersey north face necessary jacket nike air force 1 low paranoise white black
muadotho http://www.muadotho.com/
Reply tradersgalleria
4:52 AM on November 20, 2022 
tottenham grand slam polo for cheap alie saddle karrimor gilet ladies new york mets 47 brand hat pattern dallas mavericks new era cap for uk navy blue mermaid dress
tradersgalleria http://www.tradersgalleria.com/
Reply alucram
2:11 PM on November 19, 2022 
peplum bandage dress size 14 dress burberry pink cap eagles christmas hat for cheap plain red maxi dress
alucram http://www.alucram.com/
Reply lcdtvservisi
11:31 AM on November 19, 2022 
nike air force x off white volt walmart ball cap innocent wooly hats balenciaga mid speed sock sneaker baby blue maya moncler coach glovetanned leather wallet
lcdtvservisi http://www.lcdtvservisi.net/
Reply novynha
8:11 AM on November 17, 2022 
youth nike pittsburgh steelers 7 ben roethlisberger black stitched nfl limited rush jersey nike dallas cowboys 29 demarco murray white limited jersey 2090 neymar jr swoosh long sleeve polo asics gel nimbus 17 all black blue short dress for girlfriend
novynha http://www.novynha.com/
Reply nardulan
12:15 AM on November 16, 2022 
red bottom running shoes adidas golf shoes tour moncler mens black puffer jacket michael kors genuine leather crossbody handbags & purses male fairy costume adidas zx 2k boost intersport
nardulan http://www.nardulan.com/
Reply lucomania
6:18 AM on November 14, 2022 
blue air jordan 1 mid lifeproof samsung s10 plus sofia the first dress online pier one short beanie new latest fashion dress asics gold trainers
lucomania http://www.lucomania.com/
Reply cosmotelogy
9:06 PM on November 12, 2022 
pg5 black ops winter sporty outfits nice dressy outfits jordan mid black gym red red moncler body warmer klay thompson jersey amazon
cosmotelogy http://www.cosmotelogy.com/
Reply evpsistemas
12:31 AM on November 12, 2022 
banana republic plaid dress new spurs third kit readymade x nike blazer mid black elsa peretti 2 carat pendant san diego padres new era mlb cooperstown 59fifty cap answers black jersey skater dress
evpsistemas http://www.evpsistemas.com/
Reply tenminutemba
11:34 AM on November 11, 2022 
toddler hat knitting pattern with ear flaps 7.5 cotton on denim pinafore dress 1993 toronto blue jays hat 80 black leather coach hobo stilettos red sole pandora sparkle earrings
tenminutemba http://www.tenminutemba.com/
Reply nospinw
11:00 AM on November 9, 2022 
fairy godmother pandora charm ralph lauren denim shirt womens charm pandora grandmother juventus stadium dream league soccer 2019 for cheap unmatched graham shayne jersey houston texans 17 men white game jersey nike nfl jersey sale mens san diego padres 2 johnny manziel grey new cool base jersey
nospinw http://www.nospinw.com/
Reply fanclubes
4:58 PM on November 4, 2022 
new fancy party wear dress nike jordan bucket hat for cheap adidas nemeziz 19.1 black dress of the month club 70s clothes style nike steelers knit hat fund
fanclubes http://www.fanclubes.com/
Reply rudere
7:04 AM on November 4, 2022 
blank camo snapback hats for eu asos flower dress red white dress nfl pro bowl for cheap michael kors black leather clutch wrap around arrow ring pandora
rudere http://www.rudere.com/
Reply fatimahb
3:52 AM on November 4, 2022 
spain 2008 kit
fatimahb http://www.fatimahb.com/